Confidence:StrongSolidPlausibleTentativeSpeculative

• Sygg, Wanderwine Wisdom // Sygg, Wanderbrine Shield

  1U

  Legendary Creature — Merfolk Wizard // Legendary Creature — Merfolk RogueUW

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Reanimate

  B

  SorceryB

  Reanimate puts High Priest of Penance onto the battlefield from a graveyard without casting it, so its mana cost is never paid.
• Helping Hand

  W

  SorceryW

  Helping Hand puts High Priest of Penance onto the battlefield from a graveyard without casting it, so its mana cost is never paid.
• Unearth

  B

  SorceryB

  Unearth puts High Priest of Penance onto the battlefield from a graveyard without casting it, so its mana cost is never paid.
• Fblthp, Impossibly Lost

  1U

  Legendary Creature — HomunculusU

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Grave Researcher // Reanimate

  2BB

  Creature — Troll Warlock // SorceryB

  Grave Researcher puts High Priest of Penance onto the battlefield from a graveyard without casting it, so its mana cost is never paid.
• The Beast, Deathless Prince

  2BR

  Legendary Creature — DemonBR

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Vraska the Unseen

  3BG

  Legendary Planeswalker — VraskaBG

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Cryoshatter

  U

  Enchantment — AuraU

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Sleep Magic

  U

  Enchantment — AuraU

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Wayta, Trainer Prodigy

  RGW

  Legendary Creature — Human WarriorGRW

  Wayta, Trainer Prodigy makes High Priest of Penance's triggered ability trigger an additional time — each time it fires, you get it twice. Value, not a loop.
• Lost Jitte

  1

  Legendary Artifact — EquipmentC

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Puppet Master, String Puller

  2R

  Legendary Creature — Human Artificer VillainR

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Plague Spitter

  2B

  Creature — Phyrexian HorrorB

  Plague Spitter deals damage to many targets, fueling High Priest of Penance's damage-payoff trigger.
• Witch-king of Angmar

  3BB

  Legendary Creature — Wraith NobleB

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Swooping Pteranodon

  3RW

  Creature — DinosaurRW

  Swooping Pteranodon produces broad damage that redirects through High Priest of Penance into something useful.
• Delney, Streetwise Lookout

  2W

  Legendary Creature — Human ScoutW

  Delney, Streetwise Lookout makes High Priest of Penance's triggered ability trigger an additional time — each time it fires, you get it twice. Value, not a loop.
• Volatile Rig

  4

  Artifact Creature — ConstructC

  Volatile Rig deals damage to many targets, fueling High Priest of Penance's damage-payoff trigger.
• Sporogenic Infection

  1B

  Enchantment — AuraB

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Missy

  3UBR

  Legendary Creature — Time Lord RogueBRU

  Missy produces broad damage that redirects through High Priest of Penance into something useful.
• Piru, the Volatile

  2RRWWBB

  Legendary Creature — Elder DragonBRW

  Piru, the Volatile deals damage to many targets, fueling High Priest of Penance's damage-payoff trigger.
• Roaming Throne

  4

  Artifact Creature — GolemC

  Roaming Throne makes High Priest of Penance's triggered ability trigger an additional time — each time it fires, you get it twice. Value, not a loop.
• Cracked Skull

  2B

  Enchantment — AuraB

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Frozen Solid

  1UU

  Enchantment — AuraU

  Both cards trigger on damage dealt — they fire together.
• Oros, the Avenger

  3RWB

  Legendary Creature — DragonBRW

  Oros, the Avenger deals damage to many targets, fueling High Priest of Penance's damage-payoff trigger.